Upcoming Programs:

The Future of the Past –
Collecting Ancient Art
in the 21st Century
Sponsored by the
American Committee
for Cultural Policy

Asia Society

725 Park Ave
New York, NY 10021-5088
Sunday, March 18th
Doors open 10:00am
Program 10:30 am – 12:00pm
Free to the public
Panelists:
Naman Ahuja
Kate Fitz Gibbon, CPRI
Kurt Gitter
Arthur Houghton, CPRI
James Lally
James McAndrew
Julian Raby
Marc Wilson
with Melissa Chiu, Director, Asia Society
& Vishakha Desai, President, Asia Society

National Press Club Event
Chasing Aphrodite  
January 24, 2012
at 6:30 pm

The National Press Club 529 14th St. NW, 13th Floor - Washington, DC 20045 202-662-7500

Chasing Aphrodite: The Hunt for Looted Antiquities at the World’s Richest Museum
Authors Jason Felch and
Ralph Frammolino
CPRI President Arthur Houghton
and Walters Art Gallery Director
Gary Vikan

Ruth K. Franklin Symposium on the

Arts of Africa, Oceania, and the Americas

Saturday, January 21, 2012.  9:30 AM.
Cantor Arts Center Auditorium

Cantor Arts Center at Stanford University

"Cultural Heritage and African Art:

Negotiating the Rise of Ethical and Legal Collecting Concerns.

Kate Fitz Gibbon, J.D., Santa Fe, New Mexico

Derek Fincham, J.D., Ph.D., Houston

George Okello Abungu, Ph.D., Nairobi, Kenya

Sylvester Okwunodo Ogbechie, Ph.D, UC  Santa Barbara

John Henry Merryman, Dept. of Art, Stanford University

Western Museums Association
76th Annual Meeting

September 23-26, 2011

Hawai‘i Convention Center, Honolulu
Two Programs!
WMA Business Luncheon Keynote Address
Monday Sept. 26
with Kate Fitz Gibbon
Cultural Policy Research Institute
Art vs. the Law

then
Sunday Sept. 25
Safeguarding the Past:
An Exploration in the Illicit Trafficking of
Cultural Artifacts.

with:
Erika Lehman, Membership Coordinator, Iolani Palace
Kevin Shimoda, Private Investigator, Office of the Inspector General
Marcellin Abong, Director, Vanuatu Cultural Centre
Kate Fitz Gibbon, Attorney and Author, Cultural Policy Research Institute



Art, Collecting, and the Law

Monday, August 15,2011 7 PM-9 PM
Bonnie Magness-Gardner, FBI Art Crime Program
David Hall, Esq. Justice Department
FBI Special Agent David Kice
Kate Fitz Gibbon, Esq., CPRI
W. Roger Fry, Esq., ATADA
Wilbur Norman, ATADA

March 21, 2011

Russell Senate Office Building 485

Washington, D.C.


CPRI Presented

The Cultural Property Implementation Act:
Is It Working?

Transcript

Summary


May 21, 2011
CPRI files Freedom of Information Act Requests with the Department of State and Customs and Border Protection
CPRI‎ > ‎Cultural Property Laws‎ > ‎

Federal Act on the International Transfer of Cultural Property

Federal Act on the International Transfer of Cultural

Property

(Cultural Property Transfer Act, CPTA)

dated June 20, 2003

The Federal Assembly of the Swiss Confederation,

Pursuant to Articles 69, para. 2 and 95, para. 1, of the Swiss Federal Constitution1,

in execution of the UNESCO Convention from November 14, 19702 on the Means

of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of

Ownership of Cultural Property (UNESCO Convention 1970),

after having examined the Message of the Federal Council dated November 21,

20013,

decides:

Section 1: General Provisions

Article 1 Scope and Purpose

1 This Act regulates the import of cultural property into Switzerland, its transit and

export as well as its repatriation from Switzerland.

2 With this Act, the Confederation desires to make a contribution to the maintenance

of the cultural heritage of mankind and prevent theft, looting, and illicit import and

export of cultural property.

Article 2 Terms

1 Cultural property is defined as significant property from a religious or universal

standpointfor archeology, pre-history, history, literature, arts or sciences belonging

to the categories under Article 1 of the UNESCO Convention of 1970.

2 Cultural heritage is considered the entirety of cultural property belonging to one

of the categories under Article 4 of the UNESCO Convention 1970.

 

1 SR 101

2 BBl 2002 635

3 BBl 2002 535

Cultural Property Transfer Act

3 Contracting states are considered states having ratified the UNESCO Convention

of 1970.

4 Specialized body refers to the administrative body responsible for executing the

tasks outlined in Article 18.

5 Illicit import refers to an import in violation of an agreement in terms of Article 7

or a measure in terms of Article 8, para. 1, letter a.

Section 2 Registries of Cultural Property

Article 3 Federal Registry

1 Cultural property of the Confederation of significant importance for the cultural

heritage is registered in the Federal Registry.

2 The registration has the following effect:

a. cultural property may neither be acquired by adverse possession nor

acquired in good faith;

b. the claim for return is not subject to a statute of limitation;

c. the definitive export of the cultural property from Switzerland is prohibited.

3 The registration of cultural property in the Federal Registry may be removed, to

the extent that:

a. the cultural property no longer has a significant importance to the cultural

heritage;

b. consolidation speaks in favor of an ensemble;

c. the Confederation loses its title to the cultural property or waives the same.

4 The specialized body operates the Federal Registry in the form of an electronic

database and publishes the same.

Article 4 Cantonal Registries

1 To simplify checks at the borders, the Cantons, which regulate the export of

cultural property within their territories, may connect to the federal database:

a. rrrregistries of their cultural property;

b. registries of privately-owned cultural property, to the extent approval to this

end is granted by the private party.

2 The Cantons may declare that cultural property in their registries may neither be

acquired through adverse possession nor in good faith and that the claim of return is

not subject to a statute of limitations.

Cultural Property Transfer Act

Section 3: Import and Export

Article 5 Export Permit for Cultural Property Registered in the Federal

Registry

1 Whoever desires to export cultural property registered in the Federal Registry from

Switzerland requires authorization of the specialized body.

2 Authorization shall be granted if:

a. the cultural property is exported on a temporary basis; and

b. the export occurs for reasons of research, conservation, exhibition, or similar

reasons.

Article 6 Swiss Repatriation Claims

1 The Federal Council will claim the right of repatriation vis-à-vis all other

contracting states should cultural property registered in the Federal Registry be

illicitly exported from Switzerland. Any compensation and costs will be carried by

the Confederation.

2 The Federal Council will claim the right of repatriation at the request of a Canton

vis-à-vis all other contracting states should cultural property registered in a cantonal

registry be illicitly exported from Switzerland. Any compensation and costs will be

carried by the requesting Canton.

Article 7 Agreements

1 For the protection of cultural and foreign affairs interests and to secure cultural

heritage, the Federal Council may conclude international treaties with contracting

states on the import and repatriation of cultural property (Agreements).

2 The following conditions must be fulfilled:

a. the scope of the agreement must be cultural property of significant

importance to the cultural heritage of the contracting state in question;

b. the cultural property must be subject to export provisions in the state in

question for the purpose of protecting cultural heritage; and

c. the contracting state must grant reciprocal rights.

Article 8 Limited Measures

1 To protect a state’s cultural heritage jeopardized by exceptional events, the Federal

Council may:

a. enable the import, transit, and export of cultural property, tie it to

conditions, limitations, or prohibitions;

Cultural Property Transfer Act

b. participate in common international actions in terms of Article 9, UNESCO

Convention of 1970.

2 The measures must be limited in time.

Article 9 Repatriation Claims based on Agreements

1 Whoever possesses cultural property illicitly imported into Switzerland, can be

sued for repatriation by the country from which the cultural property was illicitly

exported. In particular, the country filing suit must show that the cultural property is

of significant importance to its cultural heritage and was imported illicitly.

2 The court can suspend the execution of repatriation until such time as the cultural

property is no longer in jeopardy during repatriation.

3 The country filing suit carries the costs for measures necessary for securing,

maintaining, and repatriating the cultural property.

4 Claims for repatriation by a state are subject to a statute of limitation of one year

after its authorities gain knowledge of where and with whom the cultural property is

located, at the latest, however, 30 years after the cultural property is illicitly

exported.

5 Whoever acquires cultural property in good faith and must return the same, has a

claim for compensation at the time of repatriation, oriented to the purchase price as

well as necessary and useful expenses for protecting and maintaining the cultural

property.

6 The state filing suit must pay the compensation. The person required to return the

cultural property retains a right of retention of the same until compensation is paid.

Section 4: Return Guarantee

Article 10 Request

Should cultural property of one contracting state be on temporary loan for an

exhibition in a museum or another cultural institute in Switzerland, the institution

loaning the cultural property may request that the specialized body issue a return

guarantee to the loaning institution for the period of the exhibition as stipulated in

the loan agreement.

Article 11 Publication and Procedures for Objections

1 The request is published in the Federal Bulletin. The publication contains a precise

description of the cultural property and its origin.

2 If the request clearly fails to fulfill the conditions for issuing a return guarantee,

the request will be denied and not published.

Cultural Property Transfer Act

3

 Parties pursuant to provisions of the Federal Act on Administration Procedure

from December 20, 19684, may file an objection in writing to the specialized body

within 30 days. The deadline commences with publication.

4

 Failure to file an objection, precludes the parties from further action.

Article 12 Issuance

1 The specialized body decides on the request for issuing a return guarantee.

2 The return guarantee may be issued in the event that:

a. no person claims ownership to the cultural property through an objection;

b. the import of the cultural property is not illicit;

c. the loan agreement stipulates that the cultural property will be returned to

the contracting state of origin following the conclusion of the exhibition.

3 The Federal Council may establish additional requirements.

Article 13 Effect

The return guarantee means that neither private parties nor authorities may make

legal claims to the cultural property as long as the cultural property is located in

Switzerland.

Section 5:

Financial Assistance to the Benefit of Maintaining Cultural Heritage

Article 14

1 The Confederation may grant financial assistance:

a. to museums or similar institutions in Switzerland for the temporary fiduciary

custody and conservatory care of cultural property that is part of the cultural

heritage of another state and is in jeopardy in that state due to exceptional

events;

b. for projects to maintain the cultural heritage of other contracting states;

c. under exceptional circumstances to ease the restitution of the cultural

heritage of contracting states.

2 Financial assistance pursuant to paragraph 1, letter a, may only be paid out when

the fiduciary custody:

a. occurs in agreement with the authorities of the other state; or

b. occurs under the auspices of UNESCO or another international organization

for the protection of cultural property.

 

4 SR 172.021

Cultural Property Transfer Act

Section 6: Conveyance of Cultural Property

Article 15 Conveyance to Federal Institutions

1 Federal institutions are prohibited from acquiring or exhibiting cultural property

that:

a. was stolen, lost against the will of the owner or illegally excavated;

b. are part of the cultural heritage of a state and have been illicitly exported

from the same.

2 Federal institutions offered such property must immediately report it to the

specialized body.

Article 16 Duty of Diligence

1 In the art trade and auctioning business, cultural property may only be transferred

when the person transferring the property may assume, under the circumstances, that

the cultural property:

a. was not stolen, not lost against the will of the owner, and not illegally

excavated;

b. not illicitly imported.

2 Persons active in the art trade and auctioning business are obligated:

a. to establish the identity of the supplier or seller and require a written

declaration from the same of his or her right to dispose of the cultural

property;

b. to inform their customers about existing import and export regulations of the

contracting states;

c. to maintain written records on the acquisition of cultural property by

specifically recording the origin of the cultural property, to the extent

known, and the name and address of the supplier or seller, a description as

well as the sales price of the cultural property;

d. to provide to the specialized body all necessary information on fulfilling this

duty of diligence.

3 The records and receipts must be stored for 30 years. Article 962, para. 2, Swiss

Law of Obligations5, applies accordingly.

 

5 SR 220

Cultural Property Transfer Act

Article 17 Inspection

1 To inspect adherence to duty of diligence, the specialized body has access to

business rooms and storage areas of persons active in the art trade and auctioning

business.

2 When the body has reasonable suspicion that criminal activity is present under this

Act, the specialized body will file a complaint with the competent criminal

prosecution authorities.

 Section 7: Authorities

Article 18 Specialized body

The Confederation appoints a specialized body for the execution of this Act,

specifically assuming the following tasks:

a. advising and supporting the Federal Authorities on issues of the transfer of

cultural property and coordinating the corresponding work;

b. advising the cantonal authorities on issues of the transfer of cultural property

and working together with them;

c. representing Switzerland vis-à-vis foreign authorities on issues of the

transfer of cultural property;

d. working together with authorities from other states to secure their cultural

heritage;

e. providing information on issues of the transfer of cultural property to

persons active in the art trade and auctioning business as well as other

interested circles;

f. maintaining a listing of information centers on reported stolen cultural

property;

g. administering the Federal Registry in the form of an electronic database and

publishing it (Art. 3);

h. issuing return guarantees (Art. 10–13);

i. inspecting compliance to the duty of diligence of persons active in the art

trade and auctioning business (Art. 16 and 17).

Article 19 Customs

1 Customs authorities inspect the transfer of cultural property at the border.

2 They are authorized to withhold suspicious cultural property during import, transit,

and export, and report it to criminal prosecution authorities.

Cultural Property Transfer Act

3 Arrival of cultural property at customs storage facilities is considered import in

terms of this Act.

Article 20 Criminal Prosecution Authorities

1 The competent criminal prosecution authorities will order the seizure of the

cultural property when suspicion exists that the cultural property was stolen, lost

against the will of the owner or illicitly imported into Switzerland.

2 Each seizure must be reported immediately to the specialized body.

 Section 8: Official and Legal Assistance

Article 21 Official Assistance in Switzerland

The competent authorities from the Confederation, Cantons, and Municipalities

provide all the data required for the execution of this Act to each other as well as the

appropriate oversight authorities.

Article 22 International Official and Legal Assistance

1 The Federal Authorities responsible for the execution of this Act may cooperate

with competent foreign authorities and international organizations and bodies and

coordinate inquiries to the extent that:

a. it is required for the execution of this Act; and

b. the foreign authorities, international organizations or bodies are bound by

official secrecy or are subject to a corresponding duty to observe secrecy.

2 They may request delivery of required data from foreign authorities. In order to

receive the data, they may provide them data specifically on:

a. the quality, quantity, destination and location of use, purpose of use as well

as the recipients of cultural property;

b. the persons participating in the delivery or procurement of cultural property;

c. the financial arrangement of the transactions.

3 The Federal Authorities may provide the data pursuant to paragraph 2 on their own

initiative or at the request of the foreign state, to the extent that the state in question:

a. retains reciprocal rights;

b. guarantees that data will only be processed for purposes pursuant to this

Act; and

c. guarantees that the data may only be used in criminal proceedings, if legal

assistance in criminal proceedings would not be precluded by the type of

crime; in this case, the competent federal administrative authorities consult

the Federal Office of Justice in advance on the possibility of legal assistance

in criminal proceedings.

Cultural Property Transfer Act

Article 23 Relationship to the Legal Assistance Act

Legal assistance may be provided to the competent foreign authorities for violations

of this Act. Such violations are not considered as currency, trade, or economic

crimes in terms of Article 3, para. 3, Legal Assistance Act from March 20, 19816;

the procedural provisions of this Act apply accordingly.

 Section 9: Criminal Sanctions

Article 24 Misdemeanor

1 To the extent that the offence is not threatened with a higher sanction under

another provision, punishment of imprisonment up to one year or a fine up to

100,000 Swiss Francs will be imposed on whoever intentionally:

a. imports, sells, distributes, procures, acquires, or exports cultural property

stolen or otherwise lost against the will of the owner;

b. appropriates excavation finds in terms of Article 724, Swiss Civil Code7;

c. illicitly imports cultural properly or incorrectly declares the same during

import or transit;

d. illicitly exports cultural goods listed in the Federal Registry or incorrectly

declares the same during export;

2 If the offender acts negligently, the sanction is a fee of up to 20,000 Swiss Francs.

3 If the offender acts on a professional basis, the sanction is jail for up to two years

or a fine of up to 200,000 Swiss Francs.

Article 25 Violations

1 To the extent that the offense is not threatened with a higher sanction under

another provision, a person may be fined up to 20,000 Swiss Francs, who within the

art trade or auctioning business:

a. disregards the duty of diligence (Art. 16);

b. frustrates inspections (Art. 17).

2 Attempts and aiding and abetting are punishable acts.

3 Punishment may be dispensed for lesser violations.

Article 26 Violation in Businesses

Articles 6 and 7 of the Federal Act on the Administrative Penal Code from March

22, 19748 apply to violations in businesses.

 

6 SR 351.1

7 SR 210

8 SR 313.0

Cultural Property Transfer Act

Article 27 Criminal Prosecution

The Cantons are responsible for prosecuting and assessing criminal activities

pursuant to this Act.

Article 28 Seizure of Cultural Property and Assets

Cultural property and assets seized under Articles 58 and 59 of the Swiss Penal

Code9 are assigned to the Confederation. The Federal Council controls their

application. It considers the purposes of this Act to this end.

Article 29 Disclosure Requirement

The customs authorities and the competent criminal prosecution authorities are

required to disclose violations of this Act to the specialized body.

 Section 10: Appeal and Data Protection

Article 30

1 The general provisions of the Federal Act on the Organization of the Federal

Judiciary govern the complaint procedures against decrees pursuant this to Act.

2 Legislation on the protection of data governs the processing of personal data.

 Section 11: Final Provisions

Article 31 Implementation

The Federal Council shall enact the provisions for implementation.

Article 32 Amendments to Applicable Law

The following legislation is amended as follows:

1. Swiss Civil Code10

Art. 72, para. 1 and 1bis

1 Derelict natural bodies or antiquities of scientific value are the

property of the Canton where the items are found.

 

9 SR 311.0

10 SR 210

Cultural Property Transfer Act

1bisSuch items may not be sold without the permission of the

competent cantonal authorities. They can neither be acquired by

adverse possession nor acquired in good faith. The claim for return is

not subject to a statute of limitation.

Art. 728, para. 1bis

1bisUnder the reservation of statutory exceptions, the period for

adverse possession of cultural property is thirty years pursuant to

Article 2, para. 1, Cultural Property Transfer Act from June 20,

200311 .

Art. 934, para. 1bis

1bisThe claim for the return of cultural property lost against the will

of the owner in terms of Article 2, para. 1, Cultural Property Transfer

Act from June 20, 200312, is subject to a statute of limitations of one

year after the owner gains knowledge of the locations and the

ownership of the cultural property, at the latest, however, 30 years

after the property is lost.

2. Swiss Law of Obligations13

Art. 196a

c. For cultural-

property For cultural property in terms of Article 2, para. 1, Cultural Property

Transfer Act from June 20, 200314, the claim for guaranteeing the

sold rights expires one year after the purchaser discovers the fault, in

any case, however, 30 years after conclusion of the contract.

Art. 210, para. 1bis

1bisFor cultural property in terms of Article 2, para. 1, Cultural

Property Transfer Act from June 20, 200315, the claim expires one

year after the purchaser discovers the fault, in any case, however, 30

years after conclusion of the contract.

 

11 SR ...; AS ... (BBl 2003 4475)

12 SR ...; AS ... (BBl 2003 4475)

13 SR 220

14 SR ...; AS ... (BBl 2003 4475)

15 SR ...; AS ... (BBl 2003 4475)

Cultural Property Transfer Act

3. Federal Act on Private International Law from December 18, 198716

Art. 98a

3. Cultural

property The court at the domicile or registered office of the defendant or at

the location where the cultural property is located has jurisdiction for

claims to return cultural property pursuant to Article 9, Cultural

Property Transfer Act from June 20, 200317.

4. Federal Act on the Protection of Nature and Home Country from July 1,

196618

Art. 24, para. 1, provision c

1 Punishment of imprisonment for up to one year or a fine of up to 100,000 Swiss

Francs may be imposed on whoever intentionally and without justification:

c. destroys or seriously damages natural bodies or antiquities of scientific

value contained in the ground (Art. 724, para. 1, CC19);

Article 33 Non-retroactivity

This Act is not applicable retroactively. In particular, it is not applicable to

acquisition activities that took place prior to this Act entering into force

Article 34 Referendum and Effective Date

1

The present Act is subject to an optional referendum.

2

 The Federal Council shall set the date of entry into effect.

National Council, June 20, 2003 Council of States, June 20, 2003

The President: Yves Christen

The Secretary: Christophe Thomann The President: Gian-Reto Plattner

The Secretary: Christoph Lanz

Date of Publication:  July 1, 200320

Cultural Property Transfer Act

Expiration of the referendum deadline:  October 9, 2003

 

16 SR 291

17 SR ...; AS ... (BBl 2003 4475)

18 SR 451

19 SR 210

20 BBl 2003 4475

Sign in  |  Recent Site Activity  |  Terms  |  Report Abuse  |  Print page  |  Powered by Google Sites